MOMS TALK: A Toddler & His Bottle

Tothood comforts and when do we wean them?

Our tots grow affectionately attached to items that make them feel comfortable.

Their wubbies, blankies, pacis and bottles; all are something to cling to in a moment of infant need.

We all buy into one form or another to help our wee ones rest easy. Sleep through a full night. Cuddle during story time. Take during car rides. It's common and accepted by most.

The problem is.....well....when do we wean them from their objects of adoration, if they have not yet weaned themselves ?

A year old?

Dare I say 2?

There's a certain point in time when other parents make their snarky comments and judge you for your toddler speaking through that paci. After all, it's bad for his teeth and speech, or so they say. Or maybe you'll get that glare as your toddler who can speak and walk perfectly well is still clinging to that blankie, a la Linus from Peanuts.

And here is my confession. I am the mother of a 2-year-old who is just now being weaned from his bedtime bottle.

He's never been a paci kid, really. He doesn't own a toy that is superglued to his hand. And although he will, on occasion, wear a blanket as a cape, he has yet to affectionally nickname one that never leaves his side.

But he has gone to bed with 4 ounces of warm milk since he was weaned from being breastfed. Often, when he's ready for bed, even he will walk to where the bottle sits in the kitchen and look at the microwave as if to say, "Isn't it my bedtime? I'm pooped."

If he wakes in the middle of the night, I find myself warming him another 2 ounces to comfort him back to dreamland so that I can scuffle back to bed and do the same.

And yes, again, he is 2. My older two did not harbor such an affection for the bottle (or a paci or blankie, for that matter). One was weaned by a year and the other maybe made it to 16 months. So why let my wee dude become so dependent on something that many see as a faux pas? Maybe even bad for his teeth with tooth decay or "bottle rot"?

It's hard to say. Mostly because it hasn't seemed to do any harm, and it comforts him. It's ritualistic, the same as reading a book, brushing his teeth and saying "I love you." He's has never slept with the bottle propped in his mouth. As a matter of fact, he would drink it until empty and we could hear it hit the floor as a sign of the little guy formally being ready to sleep.

Mind you, he's not running around town with a bottle. He is perfectly capable of drinking out of a sippy cup. This has been strictly a bedtime addiction.

Fifteen minutes of crying ensued on Night One of the bedtime bottle wean, with that sad look of "WHY Mama would you do such a thing!? I need it to sleep." He was then out like a light and seems to have accepted it only a day later. Deep sigh of relief from me, I must say.

So parents, what are your thoughts?

Jackie Fender July 14, 2011 at 04:36 PM
Recent update: Evening 3, went down not even a whimper. Two may be late from some but seems just right for this little guy.
Kim Thompson July 14, 2011 at 09:26 PM
Good work! Neither one of my kids liked pacifers, nor were they attached to the bottle post breastfeeding. They were BLANKIE kids. One child (who will remain nameless) still sleeps with theirs!
sonya lotter August 16, 2011 at 06:52 PM
I am about to attempt taking them off ( yes twins) bless my soul< and i have not been looking forward to this, but know its better for them as they have interupted sleep patterns due to wanting the bottle. I breastfed up till 23 and a half months and never had a nights prblems and now it is down to 6 bottles a night, No can do, so here goes, wich me luck.
Jackie Fender August 16, 2011 at 07:16 PM
You are a brave woman Sonya. The best of luck to you! I agree as far as breastfeeding. Made it to the 8 month mark-got a good amount of rest. 6 bottles at night, it's time. :) When it's over you will feel so much better.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »